Meet PubMed Commons: The new comments forum in PubMed

Image of comments icon

If you are one of the millions of people who visit PubMed today, be on the look-out for something different. On each abstract page, there’s now a section called PubMed Commons. It’s a forum for scientific discussion on publications open to any authors in the world’s largest biomedical literature database.

Several hundred comments have been made during a closed pilot in the last few months. But there are over 23 million articles in PubMed, with thousands more pouring in every day, from Tuesday to Saturday. So the chance of coming across an article with comments is still very low.

We’ll show you some interesting ones shortly, though – and you can learn how to look for articles with comments and set up alerts in one of last week’s blog posts. Or you can check out the stream of selected new comments – as well as articles that are trending in PubMed – at the PubMed Commons home page.

If you happen onto an article that has comments, the first sign will be in your search results. There will be a little icon letting you know an article has comments, and how many there are – like this:

Comment icon with number 7

Anyone can read the comments. Members may also have rated their helpfulness, which looks like this on the comment:

8 out of 8 found this helpful

Each comment comes with a “Permalink.” That’s a permanent link you can use to share the comment or cite it. You can find more about how to cite a comment in the PubMed Commons FAQs.

If a comment has cited another article in PubMed, and used particular PubMed Commons formatting to do it, you will see a note letting you know it is mentioned in a PubMed comment.

If you are the author of any publication in PubMed, you are eligible to join PubMed Commons now. PubMed Commons is a pilot, beginning an evaluation phase. Through that time, we’ll be exploring possible ways to widen participation.

Registered members of the Commons can invite others to join. We have developed a wizard to help you and your colleagues work out who can get the ball rolling. Check out the new instructions and get started today.

Then you could rate whether a comment was helpful or not, join in a discussion, or make a new comment on an article. For members of PubMed Commons who are also signed into their NCBI account, the PubMed Commons section looks like this:

Screenshot of member view of PubMed Commons showing name and commenting box

Members have already used PubMed Commons in many ways:

There are more examples in our recent post on how authors are using PubMed Commons. We will be blogging in detail about other ways people are using the Commons, as well as talking about new features under development and offering tips about making comments and using the system.

We’re looking forward to our first Twitter chat soon, too, so keep your eye out on @PubMedCommons and this blog for the announcement.

If you’re an author we hope you will join and contribute by rating comments – and adding your thoughts about scientific publications, too. Thanks again to the hundreds of people who contributed to the development of PubMed Commons this year, and the discussion about it. And welcome to everyone who is new to the Commons: we hope you will visit the home page and find out more!

The PubMed Commons team

More information:

How to join PubMed Commons

PubMed Commons FAQs

PubMed Commons Guidelines (Updated version on 19 December 2013)

One thought on “Meet PubMed Commons: The new comments forum in PubMed

  1. PubMed Commons would be more useful if we can make comments using psudoname while register with real name. In this way, more critical/useful comments will be received while still keeping the commentor responsible. This will serve the goal of this tool and the Science as a whole much better.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s